UserPreferences

PaceDuplicateIdsEntryOrigin


Abstract

State the atom:entries from the same feed with the same ID are the same entry, whether simulateously in the feed document or not.

Status

Retracted by the author -- see PaceAtomIdDos instead

Rationale

Proposal

in format-08:

1. Remove this bullet point from 4.1.1:

atom:feed elements MUST NOT contain atom:entry elements with identical atom:id values.

2. Add the following paragraph, either to atom:entry or atom:feed, at the editors' discretion (instead of the first sentence proposed by PaceAllowDuplicateIDs, if accepted):

If multiple atom:entry elements originating in the same Atom feed have the same atom:id value, whether they exist simultaneously in one document or in different instances of the feed document, they describe the same entry.

Impacts

Notes


CategoryProposals